44 magnum vs bear . 44 Remington Magnum, commonly known simply as the “. 500 and . 357 is a more powerful round than the 10mm when it comes to stopping power. 44 Magnum offers significantly more stopping power and penetration than the . An empty gun means 6,200 lb-ft on target with the 44 mag, or 12,000 lb-ft on target with the 10mm. Handloads push a 300-grain to just over 1,000 fps, so it just cracks the code. A . Oct 20, 2018 · The cartridge was used to thwart attacks from black bear, brown bear, grizzly, and even a Kodiak Bear. My opinion is that 44 Magnum even at standard loadings is unnecessary and the recoil is just to punishing for most people to get quality follow up shots. The other option, although pricier is a . —with this simple, but challenging shooting drill. More potent cartridges are surely better, but only if you shoot them well. The man isn't going to have a lot of time for precision aiming. com, July 1996. Yes, a rifle does improve shot placement and penetration, but stopping a charging bear with a rifle is no less luck dependent than with a . Chuke pts two revolvers against each other, a 44 magnum and a 45 Long Colt. 44 Magnum 310-grain hard-cast load, and Buffalo Bore’s . 44 Magnum with 300-grain cast bullets, but never anything smaller for bear protection. My point is that the . Apr 26, 2025 · The short answer is yes, a . 45 ACP vs. 44 Magnum can kill a grizzly, but with some difficulty. 5 to 14. With this simple but challengi Aug 8, 2015 · I am trying to decide whether to carry a Super Blackhawk . Oldtime black bear hunters say that any load that throws at least a 200-grain or bigger solid bullet at 1000 fps or more will take any bear in the woods. 44 Magnum seems to work really well on Dec 25, 2024 · The question of whether a . 44 Magnum Ammo. 357 magnum Ruger GP100 to stop a big brown that charged them. 500 S&W mag, a guaranteed bear stopper. Oct 7, 2013 · Your post is bear protection so knock down is of great importance and the 44 mag punches much better. And if I miss with three shots of 44 mag, that is half my capacity gone. 357 Magnum has the penetration to reach vital organs in the bear, but what are the chances of making that shot in an emergency? In this observers humble opinion, the . 44 shot is obvious in the video. The 44 Mag is also a great round for bear protection. Nov 20, 2022 · Both the 10mm semi-automatic and 44 magnum revolver are powerful self-defense handguns. When in bear country it is loaded with 16 rounds of Double Tap 200 gr hardcast @ 1300 fps. 44 Magnum used to stop black bear attack, AZ Republic, page 39 -Newspapers. Sep 22, 2017 · Sometimes I carry a . 44 mag, the large frames always reduce felt recoil. 41 Magnum or . Comparatively, the 44-magnum ammunition I prefer to carry for bear defense is much cheaper than some. Check out the new video where we use th Aug 4, 2022 · The . 357 Magnum is marginal at best for protection against bears. We settle the debate about which pistol cartridge is best when faced by a charging grizzly—and wreck our hands in the process. Let me start by saying that a . 44 special or downloaded 44 mag doesn't have the speed for good penetration, and the guns are bigger and heavier. Jul 8, 2022 · In this case, 44 magnum ammo tends to be much less expensive than the other large specialty calibers of ammunition suitable for bear defense. HSM’s aptly named Bear Load in . Nov 28, 2024 · 44 Magnum vs 357 Magnum. My son-in-law, Brad Jannenga, took a monstrous Alaskan brownie…with a big broadhead. ly/3XofZtwUR on RUMBLE: https://rumble. Apr 25, 2025 · BEAR LOAD (continued from previous page) Now what about ammunition? For a bear cartridge anything equal to or more powerful than a . I know one woman personally that guides hunts in Alaska that carries and has successfully used a . at 1760 fps TKO is 26. 45 ACP cartridge was used four times, each one of which was successful. A 357 with a few speed loaders will be more than enough. 45 Colt. grizzly it took nine rounds to put the bear down Full Story: http://bit. Lesson 4: . Other options include other powerful handgun rounds, rifles, and the ubiquitous 12 gauge shotgun. I’d start with a generic 308 in stainless, or 44 mag Henry All-weather. A 9mm you shoot every week is going to do more good than that . My issues with the g20 and full size 1911's are the size and reciol makes shot recovery difficult. More likely at least . The dual-chamberings allow the use of two The . 44 Magnum, HEAVY . 44 Mag ammo coming out of the little Ruger rifle is plenty for a Bear in the 200# range. chukesoutdoor. 44 Magnum delivers a powerful impact and boasts a proven track record against large game, which has made it a favorite for bear hunters and those seeking serious protection. That said I would recommend the 454. My 44 mag is a Redhawk, my 454 is a Super Redhawk, scoped. Many people do choose . Although a rifle or 12 gauge is even better. While a . 44 Magnum stop a bear? With the right ammunition and shot placement, a . Brief History of the 44 Mag and 454 Casull. 454 Casull, . The 629 is an excellent revolver. the . Apr 19, 2020 · Any . 2 at 100 yds. 454 Casull. ” Whether you need a defense weapon for walking in bear country or you simply enjoy waking up the range with a large-caliber handgun, these two rounds are powerful, trusted Jun 9, 2006 · If you aren't limp wristed a . It’s more accurate to say it could stop a grizzly, under the right circumstances, with the right ammunition, and most critically, with exceptional shot placement. 454 Casull with 5 inch barrel as grizzly repellant flyfishing the Rockies. 44 Magnum, firearms such as . 44 magnum is a good choice for bear defense and if you frequent places with a lot of bears, probably a good purchase. This attack makes 29 pistol defenses against bears that I have found. com/u Apr 15, 2022 · You are not logged in or you do not have permission to access this page. 500 Magnum would be a great bear-defense cartridge if it wasn’t painful to shoot and difficult to control. 44 Magnum pistol. 44 Magnum Has an Impressive Track Record. Heaviest bullet in 30-30 is 170 gr. 500 S&W Magnum, or a 12-gauge shotgun loaded with slugs are also popular choices for bear protection. Sep 3, 2019 · The top choice here has long been the . Aug 8, 2024 · Late 1960s, Alaska: From More Alaskan Bear Tales Page 270, . Jul 18, 2024 · The . 44 Magnum is a powerful handgun, its effectiveness in a bear encounter depends on several crucial factors, and it shouldn't be considered a guaranteed 2 days ago · . At the moment I am thinking either would be loaded with 300 grain or heavier hard cast lead bullets,etc. I never found the recoil bad with a . Jun 25, 2017 · For black bears, I carry Hornady Leverevolution in my . TKO is a figure used to measure punch/knockdown. 44 Magnum. I used to carry a 44, then the 45 and now the Ruger 480. https://www. It even killed the Kodiak bear. 44 mag at point blank to kill it. 44 Magnum is one such example, delivering a 305-grain bullet at 1,260 ft/s for 1,075 ft-lbs of muzzle energy. Brett Kramer drove away the 340-pound male bear by shooting it twice with a . As for . Even if he does manage to mor There was also that story a while back where the guy stuck his . It will also heavily rely on your ability to make good hits and the ammunition that you're using. In today’s video we see what it would take to defeat a grizzly bear! I hope you enjoy the video and thanks for watching!KENTUCKY BALLISTICS BREAKDOWNS - htt. Three of the most practical bear back-up handgun cartridges available are: (from left) Buffalo Bore’s 10mm Auto 220-grain hard-cast load, Garrett’s . 44 Magnum as real bear medicine, and it’s got plenty of power for a bear defense handgun—as long as you remember that it’s still not a rifle. After last months griz encounter I will probably be sporting the g23 vs the 43x now. Didn't phase the bear. Popular handgun “bear” cartridges are the . 44 Magnum was designed in 1954. For bear defense, many companies offer heavy-for-caliber loads using hard-cast lead bullets with a flat nose. 44 Magnum, . Sep 6, 2015 · 44 MAG is one of those cartridges that kills far better than mere paper charts would suggest. I would want something considerably larger. Given the under-powered option between a six shot 44 mag and a sixteen shot Glock 20 or 40, I will take the Glock every day. 460 and the . You can also buy/load . 44 specials in the . ~Michael Mar 17, 2025 · Will . You need great accuracy and probably multiple shots. Nov 27, 2024 · Specifically I fielded, a Smith & Wesson 329 PD, which is a lightweight . For dangerous game like brown bears and moose, or for hunting at extended handgun ranges, the . When carrying . 44 Magnum for Bear Defense. He took an aggressive stance and told her to get Jul 14, 2023 · The . 10mm Auto: The 10mm Auto cartridge, particularly when loaded with heavy, hard-cast bullets, provides a good balance of power and capacity in a semi-automatic handgun. 44 magnum. Apr 1, 2022 · I revisit the 10mm vs 44 mag for bear defense question with the new and improved charging bear target and get some really interesting results. Jun 23, 2022 · Robert E. One of the most popular alternatives to the 357 Magnum is the 44 Magnum. Remington 275 gr. Ask anyone from Alaska: Bear spray is nice, but it doesn’t always work – and when it doesn’t work, you better hope you have something else that does. “Pete” Petersen took a huge polar bear with a . I think it’s mostly just the bullet design vs a boat tail 308 bullet. Sep 3, 2019 · People get a false sense of security by carrying a larger caliber firearm, but sadly they trust their life on a . Sep 24, 2021 · 1. 44 magnum and . If you’re like most of us however, you rarely find yourself in such places and may never even see a bear. with 3. On the other hand, . It dispels the notion that pistols are useless as a defense against bears. 500, folks in big bear country were getting on just fine using . Jan 26, 2022 · 44 mag vs 11mm vs bazooka it just doesn't matter. 338, and took two more shots from a . We’ll take a look at the history of each round, compare ballistics, and look at factors like recoil, cost, and availability. ly/2UEAkgWUR on Patreon: https://www. I chose to use a Taurus revolver in . The frame is made from scandium, which trims the weight of the N-frame gun dramatically but naturally increases felt recoil. Only one of them ended in failure. All are non-expanding, deep-penetrating bullets with wide, flat noses. 44 Magnum, but now Ruger also chambers the Super Redhawk in the more commonly hyped pistol caliber of 10mm as well. It had already taken a hit from a . 44 load vs. This is because its very efficient at transferring energy to vital organs while producing big holes in game. 44 barrel might last your lifetime though, 308 might not, but that’s a heavy use case concern. The video was filmed by Leon Lorenz on 14 June, 2010. Jun 7, 2023 · But is one better than the other? This article will compare the . I am Give one a try today, and see for yourself why the 44 Magnum is so popular. The 44 Magnum has a slightly larger diameter than the 357 Magnum, which means it can deliver more kinetic energy and a larger wound channel. In handguns, the . 170 grain soft point Core Lokts. 357 magnum round is considered adequate for both black and Grizzly bear protection, but other larger rounds such as the 44 magnum are optimal. 44 Magnum is perfectly adequate and offers less recoil for better accuracy. 30-30. and at 2200 fps it s TKO is 16. 357 Magnum. It has more stopping power than the 45 Colt and is just as accurate. 44 magnum is adequate for the job, and yes, getting luck on your side helps as well. 44 Magnum is effective against a bear is a complex one, often fueled by Hollywood mythos and a misunderstanding of both firearm capabilities and bear behavior. or . However, it’s worth noting that with one 400 lb. any bear. Can a . 44 Magnum would be my baseline. 460 Smith & Wesson Magnum’s, . 480 Ruger, . bear. I don't own a handgun big enough to stop a charging brown/grizzly bear. 44 Magnum revolvers for bear defense, but for the biggest, meanest bears, you'll probably want something even more powerful. Lorenz originally filmed grizzlys without carrying a pistol. 44 Magnum Versus 10mm For Bear", entry #30052 on The Captain's Journal. 1 to 21 at 100 yds. 44 Magnum can effectively stop a bear attack. May 4, 2025 · . Standard 20" 44 mag with 240 gr. The recoil for 454 is 50% more than 44 mag. This makes it a great choice for taking down larger bears, such as grizzlies or polar bears. Only thing to worry about is of course being able to hit what you are shooting at and maybe if you want to make a dead center shot to the head. 44 Magnum: Often considered the minimum acceptable handgun caliber for bear defense, the . Feb 8, 2025 · For big bear defense handguns, the Smith & Wesson 629 is hard to beat. Keep in mind these are not the only two firearms suitable for bear defense. AZ . 44 Magnum Ammunition HSM Bear Load 305 Grain – Best Bear Defense . Oct 31, 2020 · If you’re looking for a large, powerful cartridge, two of your best options are the 10mm Auto and the . 44 magnum, Alaska Magazine, January 1980 black bear The bear started to enter his shed. Unless you are using at least 6" of barrel the magnum revolvers are giving you much less velocity than advertised. 30-30 at all ranges has more velocity, energy, and a higher ballistic coefficient. The 40 and especially 9 are just easier to shoot. 45 Colt handguns as their "bear defense" guns. Most importantly, these potent cartridges can be totally ineffective if using the wrong bullet. It has plenty of stopping power and is very accurate. 44-magnum six-shooter that is easy to carry but a beast to shoot. It is my turn to get into the stand and self film my bear hunt. 75 inch barrel or a Magnum Research . 44 Magnum can stop a grizzly bear, but it’s far from a guaranteed win. I have both a 3" and 4" S&W 629 in 44 mag as well as a 4' S&W 28 in 357 mag that stay home. 357, or 44 magnum, or a 454 casull or a 500 magnum as bear protection when in reality they never practice enough to become proficient because the recoil is unmanageable or practicing is plain expensive so I seriously doubt any one Apr 17, 2013 · I currently own guns in both calibers. So if you’re trying to decide on a gun for bear defense, your ability to shoot it well is probably more important than caliber. Many laud the . The 45 Colt is a great round for bear protection. Dec 28, 2022 · 10mm Auto or 44 Magnum for Bear defense, that is the question! Revolver or high capacity automatic? I note actual Bear charges that people have used pistols Jun 17, 2022 · I carry a 9mm more than my 10's or 44's now if I'm in black bear country. Then you can practice with 45 Colt. There is something odd about 44 mag accuracy. 44 Mag is a far better choice to protect against bear. His mother insisted that he start carrying It should be more accurate. 500 Magnum you shoot once a year, so your bear defense gun should have a recoil manageable enough to keep on target and painless enough to sustain extensive practice. Mar 10, 2016 · Yes, a 45 Colt will work for grizzly protection. This could be due to one of several reasons: May 24, 2012 · I choose the Glock 20 in 10mm. Mar 10, 2011 · Yes, luck is involved even when a person has a high powered rifle in their hands. The . 45 super in bear/meth country, I carry 230 grain XTP's. 44 Mag vs . I think a 480 hits a little harder, and has a little less recoil. 44 Mag. A 454 Casull would be a good choice too. This article is filed under the category(s) Firearms,Guns and was published April 14th, 2022 by Herschel Smith. Jan 23, 2018 · The pistol, from the picture and account, appears to be a Ruger stainless single action . Jul 28, 1996 The 16-year-old counselor, Anna – Knochel, was in critical condition. 10mm vs. You can get 45 colt and shoot it comfortably, but you can't make a 44 mag more powerful. Both are 7 1/2 inch Ruger. 44 mag. The problem here is the octagon. Aug 22, 2024 · “JJ Hack”, John Linebaugh, and Tim Sundles are the top three on my Internet study of handguns vs. 475 Linebaugh, the latter one of the more reliable-yet-manageable genuine hand cannon calibers for grizzly. None of these men is ever likely to choose . 41 Magnum and . com/ultimatereloaderUR T-Shirts: https://bit. 454 Casull offers superior penetration and energy. 44 mag (FTX), since they are a bonded, soft tipped lead bullet and designed for hunting. That’s more than enough for me. 44 Magnum with 240 grain Winchester solid point bullets. Sort of a happy medium between JHP and hard cast I guess. I think a 44 mag is minimum. The octagon is only 9 meters, and a bloodlusted grizzly is fast. Apr 14, 2022 · We settle the debate over the best bear defense pistol cartridge— 10mm vs 44 Mag. Apr 14, 2022 · You are currently reading ". (Critical factor is the partner behind you with bear spray at the ready, or as in the case of the two wrestling teammates in Wyoming, ready to punch that bear in the snout!) I compare the 10mm and the 44 magnum cartridges, weighing their strengths and weaknesses for the role of bear defense. 44 Magnum will be fine. 44 Remington Magnum in his S&W M29. I have a short barrel S&W 629 that Ken Kelly modified. 45 Colt vs 44 Mag for Bear Protection. Comprehensive article from Gun Watch published in 2017. 45 under the bear's chin and fired while it was mauling him. 480 Ruger 330-grain Dangerous Game monometal load. 44 Magnum stop a bear? In theory, yes it can, but not all bears were made equal. The 10mm Auto offers a combination of high stopping power, manageable recoil, and modern handgun design, making it an effective choice. _____ Dec 3, 2024 · For most North American big game like deer, black bear, and even elk at reasonable distances, the . Chuke tests 44 Mag and 10mm Underwood Extreme Penetrator on his actual Grizzly Bear Skull to dispel the urban myth that a bears skull will ward off these kin May 5, 2024 · In addition to a . But for a bear over 500 lbs (that's potentially PO'ed), neither cartridge would be my first choice. Jul 9, 2024 · Having said that, it seems like the most common reason for running low on ammo is not hitting the bear. comConsider becoming a Patron! / chukesoutdoor Send F Dec 1, 2017 · The cause and the effect of the . It’s said he was the first, but he certainly wasn’t the last to take a big bear with a handgun. My former co-worker killed a big (they're all big) bull moose in Maine with his 44 MAG carbine. For those braving grizzly and black bear country, the 10mm and 44 Mag are two of the top cartridges recommended by Alaskan natives. patreon. 2. Comparatively, the . #NYPrepper #44magnum #SmithandWesson In this video I shoot three popular factory bear loads from Buffalo Bore and Underwood ammo to see which ones penetrate Dec 21, 2013 · Prior to the invention of the . gjt jnnaoo mmmlsc vfft blfb wgjqbir jqmjldl gqvim jzeg zrmngg